Amaro Milk Punch
Clarified, crystal-clear, and silkier than any cocktail has a right to be.
The Method
How to make it
- 01
Combine the amaro, rum, lemon juice and syrup in a pitcher.
- 02
Pour that mixture slowly INTO the warm milk — never the other way around — and watch it curdle.
- 03
Rest for 1 hour, then refrigerate overnight so the curds settle.
- 04
Strain through a coffee filter or fine cloth; re-pour the first cloudy runnings back through until it runs clear.
- 05
Bottle and refrigerate. Serve 3 oz over a large cube with a lemon twist.
Bartender's Tip
Liquid into milk, never milk into liquid, or the curd forms in one dense lump and clarifies nothing. And do not rush the filter — gravity does the work overnight.
A Little History
Milk punch dates to 17th-century England — Benjamin Franklin sent a recipe in a 1763 letter, and bottles were known to keep for decades. The milk proteins bind tannins and bitter compounds, which makes the technique uncannily well-suited to amaro.
Shop this drink
The bottle, the glass, and the kit — everything on this card.
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure.
Newsletter
The Bitter Brief
One short Friday dispatch: a bottle worth buying, a cocktail worth mixing, and a little Italian history.
Mix another
Aereo Elefante
¾ oz See the Elephant · ¾ oz Bourbon · ¾ oz Giffard Pamplemousse · ¾ oz Lemon · Basil
Elephant Flip
2 oz See the Elephant · 1 oz Cacao-infused Grappa · ¾ oz Bénédictine · 1 bsp Cocchi Dopo Teatro · Whole Egg
Paper Plane
¾ oz Bourbon · ¾ oz Amaro Nonino · ¾ oz Aperol · ¾ oz Fresh Lemon Juice